Mind the Gap: Why Generic AI Fails and How a Context-First Approach Delivers Real Business Value

A recent, must-read critique in The Guardian by AI researcher Gary Marcus offers a powerful dose of reality regarding the state of artificial intelligence. This opinion piece highlights a critical “reasoning gap” in today’s most advanced Large Language Models (LLMs), showing how even the most expensive systems can “collapse” when faced with novel problems requiring true logical reasoning.

For business leaders, this is a strategic warning that off-the-shelf AI solutions are doomed to fail. In fact, the article validates a core principle we champion at Proactive Technology Management: you cannot simply deploy a generic AI and expect it to solve specific, high-stakes business challenges reliably.

This post will explore why this reasoning gap poses a significant risk to Small and Medium-sized Businesses (SMBs) and detail how our Fusion Development approach bridges this gap. We will show how to transform a generalist AI tool into a powerful, dependable asset by grounding it in the one thing it lacks: the specific context of your business.

Acknowledging AI’s “Reasoning Gap”

The central argument of Gary Marcus’s article is that today’s LLMs, while masterful at recognizing and replicating patterns within their training data, are fundamentally unreliable when pushed beyond those boundaries. Their performance on tasks requiring novel, multi-step logic is often “hit-or-miss.”

These models were not explicitly designed for the kind of abstract, causal reasoning that business strategy demands. Instead, they are incredibly sophisticated prediction engines, best suited to reproduce variations on logic they have seen before.

This distinction is vital. Trusting a prediction engine with critical operational or financial decisions without ensuring its predictions are grounded in your specific reality is a recipe for failure.

The “reasoning gap” is the space between an AI’s general knowledge and the specialized, nuanced understanding required to drive your business forward.

The Risk for SMBs: Why Generic AI Is the New “Paving the Cow Path”

For SMBs eager to innovate, the allure of off-the-shelf AI is strong. However, adopting these tools without a clear strategy leads to a modern form of an age-old problem: “paving the cow path.” Coined by BPR pioneers Michael Hammer and James Champy, this refers to using new technology to simply automate an existing—and often flawed—process. Applying a generic AI to a broken workflow doesn’t fix the workflow; it just creates bad outcomes faster and at a greater scale.

True Business Process Re-engineering (BPR) requires a “clean sheet” approach: fundamentally rethinking a process to achieve a desired outcome with the best tools available. When an SMB trusts a generic, context-less AI for a key function, it’s not re-engineering; it’s gambling.

The unreliability of these models for specific tasks means outputs can be inconsistent and require constant human verification, negating any potential efficiency gains.

To truly leverage AI, a business must move beyond the hype and implement a framework that makes the technology both intelligent and reliable.

The Fusion Development Solution: Building Context-Aware AI That Works

At Proactive Technology Management, we see the reasoning gap not as an obstacle, but as the central challenge to be solved. Our Fusion Development methodology is built to do exactly that.

We transform general-purpose AI into a team of specialized, high-performing experts that are deeply knowledgeable about your unique business environment.

This is achieved through an iterative process of building a solid data foundation, empowering AI with specific context, and orchestrating automated workflows.

The Foundation: A Unified Data Platform

An AI’s ability to reason is entirely dependent on the information it can access.

A generic LLM knows about the world, but it knows nothing about your Q3 sales figures, your top-performing marketing campaigns, or your most complex supply chain challenges.

Our first step is always to establish this foundational layer of knowledge. We architect and implement a modern cloud data warehouse using platforms like Microsoft Fabric, which serves as your organization’s “single source of truth”.

By integrating disparate data sources from across your enterprise (ERP, CRM, spreadsheets, etc.), we eliminate the data silos that hamstring most AI initiatives.

This unified data platform becomes the essential, contextual knowledge base that fuels all subsequent AI-driven automation and decision-making, ensuring that every AI-generated insight is relevant and grounded in fact.

The Intelligence: Creating Specialized AI Agents

Once this data foundation is in place, we build the intelligent layer. Instead of relying on an AI’s generic training, we empower it with your proprietary knowledge using advanced, enterprise-grade techniques.

The result? We build custom AI copilots and intelligent agents capable of performing complex, multi-step business functions with high accuracy.

We achieve this specialization through methods such as:

• Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG): We configure AI agents to query your private, secure data warehouse in real-time. When a task arises, the agent retrieves the specific documents, data points, or process manuals it needs to formulate an accurate and contextually appropriate response. This ensures the AI’s output is based on your business reality, not its general training.
• Targeted In-Context Learning: Through sophisticated prompt engineering, we provide the AI with a rich, “just-in-time” understanding of the task at hand. By loading the AI’s context window with relevant user stories, business rules, and data schemas, we turn your internal documentation into an instruction manual for the AI. This process transforms a generalist tool into a focused expert.

The Execution: Driving Intelligent Hyperautomation

With a reliable data foundation and specialized AI agents, we can then automate and orchestrate your core business processes. This is the stage of Intelligent Hyperautomation, where we use tools like Robotic Process Automation (RPA), Intelligent Document Processing (IDP), and low-code platforms to build end-to-end automated workflows.

This goes far beyond simple task automation. It is AI-driven process orchestration. Your specialized AI agents can manage entire workflows, make real-time adjustments based on incoming data, and seamlessly collaborate with human team members on exceptions or high-judgment tasks.

This creates a dynamic, continuously improving operational system where data-driven insights immediately translate into more efficient processes, creating a virtuous cycle of optimization.

Conclusion: Making AI a Reliable, Transformative Asset

The insights from Gary Marcus’s article are not a reason to abandon AI but a clear call to adopt it strategically. The future of competitive advantage will not belong to those who simply buy AI tools, but to those who integrate them deeply into the fabric of their business.

True value is unlocked when AI is transformed from a generic know-it-all into a dedicated expert on your specific operational landscape.

Proactive Technology Management’s Fusion Development methodology provides a pragmatic roadmap for this transformation.

We specialize in AI-accelerated BPR that is right-sized for SMBs, focusing on delivering measurable ROI through an agile and iterative approach. We build solutions where you retain full ownership of your data, code, and models, empowering your organization for the long term.

By bridging the AI reasoning gap with your unique business context, we make artificial intelligence a reliable and powerful engine for your growth.

Follow Michael Weinberger on LinkedIn for more insights on AI, BPR, and SMB transformation (don’t forget to turn on alerts!).

Ready to explore how AI-accelerated BPR can transform your business? Schedule your free discovery consultation today!